| Date | Our Pick | Result |
| Apr 26 2024 | Arizona at Seattle (Seattle +110) | WINNER |
| Apr 26 2024 | Chi Cubs at Boston (Boston -110) | loss |
| Apr 26 2024 | Cincinnati at Texas (Cincinnati +143) | loss |
| Apr 26 2024 | Cleveland at Atlanta (Atlanta -270) | WINNER |
| Apr 26 2024 | Kansas City at Detroit (Kansas City +110) | WINNER |
| Apr 26 2024 | LA Dodgers at Toronto (LA Dodgers -125) | WINNER |
| Apr 26 2024 | Minnesota at LA Angels (LA Angels -120) | loss |
| Apr 26 2024 | NY Yankees at Milwaukee (NY Yankees -145) | loss |
| Apr 26 2024 | Oakland at Baltimore (Baltimore -323) | loss |
| Apr 26 2024 | Philadelphia at San Diego (Philadelphia -110) | WINNER |
| Apr 26 2024 | Pittsburgh at San Francisco (San Francisco -145) | WINNER |
| Apr 26 2024 | St Louis at NY Mets (NY Mets -125) | loss |
| Apr 26 2024 | Tampa Bay at Chi White Sox (Tampa Bay -238) | loss |
| Apr 26 2024 | Washington at Miami (Washington +105) | WINNER |
| Apr 25 2024 | Boston at Cleveland (Cleveland -120) | WINNER |
|