| Date | Our Pick | Result |
| May 3 2024 | Atlanta at LA Dodgers (Atlanta -110) | loss |
| May 3 2024 | Baltimore at Cincinnati (Baltimore +100) | WINNER |
| May 3 2024 | Boston at Minnesota (Boston +105) | loss |
| May 3 2024 | Chi White Sox at St Louis (St Louis -233) | WINNER |
| May 3 2024 | Colorado at Pittsburgh (Pittsburgh -179) | loss |
| May 3 2024 | Detroit at NY Yankees (NY Yankees -169) | WINNER |
| May 3 2024 | LA Angels at Cleveland (Cleveland -196) | loss |
| May 3 2024 | Miami at Oakland (Oakland -145) | WINNER |
| May 3 2024 | Milwaukee at Chi Cubs (Milwaukee -105) | WINNER |
| May 3 2024 | NY Mets at Tampa Bay (Tampa Bay -145) | WINNER |
| May 3 2024 | San Diego at Arizona (San Diego -115) | WINNER |
| May 3 2024 | San Francisco at Philadelphia (San Francisco +143) | loss |
| May 3 2024 | Seattle at Houston (Houston -115) | WINNER |
| May 3 2024 | Texas at Kansas City (Texas +100) | loss |
| May 3 2024 | Toronto at Washington (Toronto -204) | loss |
|