| Date | Our Pick | Result |
| May 17 2025 | Athletics at San Francisco (San Francisco -165) | WINNER |
| May 17 2025 | Atlanta at Boston (Boston -120) | WINNER |
| May 17 2025 | Chi White Sox at Chi Cubs (Chi Cubs -310) | WINNER |
| May 17 2025 | Cleveland at Cincinnati (Cincinnati -105) | WINNER |
| May 17 2025 | Colorado at Arizona (Colorado +310) | WINNER |
| May 17 2025 | Detroit at Toronto (Toronto +115) | WINNER |
| May 17 2025 | Houston at Texas (Texas -120) | WINNER |
| May 17 2025 | LA Angels at LA Dodgers (LA Dodgers -240) | loss |
| May 17 2025 | Minnesota at Milwaukee (Minnesota -125) | WINNER |
| May 17 2025 | NY Mets at NY Yankees (NY Yankees -135) | loss |
| May 17 2025 | Pittsburgh at Philadelphia (Philadelphia -330) | WINNER |
| May 17 2025 | Seattle at San Diego (San Diego -195) | loss |
| May 17 2025 | St Louis at Kansas City (St Louis -105) | WINNER |
| May 17 2025 | Tampa Bay at Miami (Tampa Bay -140) | WINNER |
| May 17 2025 | Washington at Baltimore (Baltimore -155) | loss |
|