| Date | Our Pick | Result |
| Jul 12 2026 | Arizona at LA Dodgers (LA Dodgers -216) | loss |
| Jul 12 2026 | Athletics at Chi White Sox (Chi White Sox -138) | WINNER |
| Jul 12 2026 | Atlanta at St Louis (Atlanta +122) | WINNER |
| Jul 12 2026 | Boston at NY Mets (NY Mets +104) | loss |
| Jul 12 2026 | Chi Cubs at Cincinnati (Chi Cubs -131) | WINNER |
| Jul 12 2026 | Cleveland at Miami (Cleveland -106) | WINNER |
| Jul 12 2026 | Colorado at San Francisco (San Francisco -145) | WINNER |
| Jul 12 2026 | Houston at Texas (Houston +130) | loss |
| Jul 12 2026 | Kansas City at Baltimore (Baltimore -141) | WINNER |
| Jul 12 2026 | LA Angels at Minnesota (Minnesota -122) | WINNER |
| Jul 12 2026 | Milwaukee at Pittsburgh (Milwaukee +120) | loss |
| Jul 12 2026 | NY Yankees at Washington (NY Yankees +113) | WINNER |
| Jul 12 2026 | Philadelphia at Detroit (Detroit -127) | loss |
| Jul 12 2026 | Seattle at Tampa Bay (Tampa Bay -144) | loss |
| Jul 12 2026 | Toronto at San Diego (San Diego +114) | WINNER |
|