| Date | Our Pick | Result |
| Sep 19 2021 | Arizona at Houston (Houston -180) | WINNER |
| Sep 19 2021 | Atlanta at San Francisco (San Francisco -119) | loss |
| Sep 19 2021 | Baltimore at Boston (Boston -310) | WINNER |
| Sep 19 2021 | Chi Cubs at Milwaukee (Chi Cubs +190) | WINNER |
| Sep 19 2021 | Chi White Sox at Texas (Chi White Sox -205) | WINNER |
| Sep 19 2021 | Cleveland at NY Yankees (NY Yankees -315) | loss |
| Sep 19 2021 | Colorado at Washington (Colorado -104) | loss |
| Sep 19 2021 | Detroit at Tampa Bay (Detroit +240) | WINNER |
| Sep 19 2021 | LA Dodgers at Cincinnati (LA Dodgers -176) | WINNER |
| Sep 19 2021 | Minnesota at Toronto (Toronto -215) | WINNER |
| Sep 19 2021 | Oakland at LA Angels (LA Angels +120) | loss |
| Sep 19 2021 | Philadelphia at NY Mets (NY Mets -130) | WINNER |
| Sep 19 2021 | Pittsburgh at Miami (Miami -210) | WINNER |
| Sep 19 2021 | San Diego at St Louis (St Louis -110) | WINNER |
| Sep 19 2021 | Seattle at Kansas City (Seattle -129) | WINNER |
|