| Date | Our Pick | Result |
| Sep 18 2026 | Athletics at Cleveland (Cleveland -126) | WINNER |
| Sep 18 2026 | Atlanta at Houston (Atlanta -120) | WINNER |
| Sep 18 2026 | Boston at Tampa Bay (Boston +114) | WINNER |
| Sep 18 2026 | Chi Cubs at Cincinnati (Cincinnati +109) | WINNER |
| Sep 18 2026 | Detroit at Chi White Sox (Detroit +109) | WINNER |
| Sep 18 2026 | Kansas City at Pittsburgh (Pittsburgh -191) | WINNER |
| Sep 18 2026 | Miami at San Diego (San Diego -204) | WINNER |
| Sep 18 2026 | Milwaukee at Baltimore (Baltimore +119) | loss |
| Sep 18 2026 | Minnesota at LA Angels (Minnesota -124) | WINNER |
| Sep 18 2026 | NY Yankees at Arizona (NY Yankees -131) | WINNER |
| Sep 18 2026 | Philadelphia at NY Mets (NY Mets -123) | WINNER |
| Sep 18 2026 | San Francisco at LA Dodgers (LA Dodgers -313) | WINNER |
| Sep 18 2026 | Seattle at Colorado (Seattle -186) | WINNER |
| Sep 18 2026 | Toronto at Texas (Toronto -142) | loss |
| Sep 18 2026 | Washington at St Louis (Washington -105) | WINNER |
|