| Date | Our Pick | Result |
| May 8 2025 | Baltimore at Minnesota (Baltimore +140) | loss |
| May 8 2025 | Chi White Sox at Kansas City (Kansas City -260) | WINNER |
| May 8 2025 | Cincinnati at Atlanta (Atlanta -205) | WINNER |
| May 8 2025 | Detroit (G1) at Colorado (G1) (Detroit (G1) -170) | WINNER |
| May 8 2025 | Detroit (G2) at Colorado (G2) (Colorado (G2) +170) | loss |
| May 8 2025 | LA Dodgers at Arizona (Arizona +135) | WINNER |
| May 8 2025 | Philadelphia at Tampa Bay (Philadelphia -165) | WINNER |
| May 8 2025 | Texas at Boston (Boston -160) | WINNER |
| May 8 2025 | Toronto at LA Angels (Toronto -135) | WINNER |
| May 7 2025 | Baltimore at Minnesota (Minnesota -140) | WINNER |
| May 7 2025 | Chi White Sox at Kansas City (Kansas City -225) | WINNER |
| May 7 2025 | Cincinnati at Atlanta (Atlanta -120) | loss |
| May 7 2025 | Cleveland at Washington (Washington -110) | loss |
| May 7 2025 | Detroit at Colorado (Detroit -170) | WINNER |
| May 7 2025 | Houston at Milwaukee (Milwaukee +115) | loss |
|