| Date | Our Pick | Result |
| May 26 2026 | Arizona at San Francisco (Arizona +104) | WINNER |
| May 26 2026 | Atlanta at Boston (Boston -108) | loss |
| May 26 2026 | Chi Cubs at Pittsburgh (Chi Cubs +123) | loss |
| May 26 2026 | Cincinnati at NY Mets (Cincinnati -111) | WINNER |
| May 26 2026 | Colorado at LA Dodgers (LA Dodgers -225) | WINNER |
| May 26 2026 | Houston at Texas (Texas -126) | WINNER |
| May 26 2026 | LA Angels at Detroit (Detroit -133) | loss |
| May 26 2026 | Miami at Toronto (Toronto -117) | WINNER |
| May 26 2026 | Minnesota at Chi White Sox (Minnesota -111) | WINNER |
| May 26 2026 | NY Yankees at Kansas City (NY Yankees -184) | WINNER |
| May 26 2026 | Philadelphia at San Diego (Philadelphia -103) | WINNER |
| May 26 2026 | Seattle at Athletics (Athletics -105) | loss |
| May 26 2026 | St Louis at Milwaukee (Milwaukee -196) | WINNER |
| May 26 2026 | Tampa Bay at Baltimore (Baltimore +103) | WINNER |
| May 26 2026 | Washington at Cleveland (Cleveland -124) | loss |
|