| Date | Our Pick | Result |
| Apr 18 2026 | Atlanta at Philadelphia (Atlanta +101) | WINNER |
| Apr 18 2026 | Baltimore at Cleveland (Cleveland -142) | WINNER |
| Apr 18 2026 | Chi White Sox at Athletics (Athletics -161) | WINNER |
| Apr 18 2026 | Cincinnati at Minnesota (Cincinnati +109) | WINNER |
| Apr 18 2026 | Detroit at Boston (Detroit -148) | WINNER |
| Apr 18 2026 | Kansas City at NY Yankees (NY Yankees -161) | WINNER |
| Apr 18 2026 | LA Dodgers at Colorado (LA Dodgers -290) | loss |
| Apr 18 2026 | Milwaukee at Miami (Miami -121) | loss |
| Apr 18 2026 | NY Mets at Chi Cubs (NY Mets -103) | loss |
| Apr 18 2026 | San Diego at LA Angels (San Diego -112) | WINNER |
| Apr 18 2026 | San Francisco at Washington (San Francisco -116) | WINNER |
| Apr 18 2026 | St Louis at Houston (Houston -137) | loss |
| Apr 18 2026 | Tampa Bay at Pittsburgh (Pittsburgh -148) | loss |
| Apr 18 2026 | Texas at Seattle (Seattle -137) | WINNER |
| Apr 18 2026 | Toronto at Arizona (Toronto +129) | loss |
|